Blogged By Eric

Cartoons, Films, Game Reviews and more!

The Aristocats

The Aristocats (1970)

Does Walt’s final animated feature close a chapter on his studio’s legacy?

Brief Backstory

Although the Jungle Book was the last movie Disney himself physically worked on, Disney gave the go-ahead for the Aristocats before he died in 1966.

Released in 1970, The Aristocats has been given favorable reviews by critics, although most viewers find it a little lacking in contrast to Disney’s works in the 1960s.

Story

Shun Gon who resembles one of the Siamese cats in Lady and the Tramp.

An avaricious butler, Edgar, swipes Duchess and her kittens, Marie, Toulouse, and Berlioz after realizing they inherit before him. Together with an alley cat named Thomas O’Malley, they make their journey back to Paris and back to their owner. Going back however is easier said than done, and even after all that, Edgar bags them up and hires a crew to ship them to Timbuktu in Africa.

Random Facts

Returning voice actors include Bill Thompson (White Rabbit in Alice in Wonderland and Droopy the Dog) and Phil Harris (Baloo in The Jungle Book). Eva Gabor would voice Bianca in both Rescuers movies later on. Phil Harris, Monica Evans, Pat Buttram, and George Lindsey would voice characters in Robin Hood.

Some of the animation in Everybody Wants to be a Cat is reused in Robin Hood’s Phony King of England (also sung by Phil Harris), such as some of Duchess’s movements and Shun Gon’s drumming. I believe this was due to Disney having to make sacrifices after throwing so much money away on Disneyland and Walt Disney World.

O’Malley’s movement animation is recycled from Sergeant Tibbs from 101 Dalmatians in the climatic fight scene where Edgar tries to throw a pitchfork at him.

Nominated by the AFI in 2008 for their top 10 animated films.

According to Wikipedia, and this isn’t the best source, The Aristocats was originally considered to be a double-length episode on Walt Disney’s Wonderful World of Color, an incarnation of Wonderful World of Disney that introduced Ludwig Von Drake.

Roquefort and Scat Cat

Random Opinions

Even if Edgar’s academically challenged mind wasn’t an issue, can you blame him for being pissed off about the cats getting the inheritance first? He probably had crappy pay and long hours, much like how I did at Advance Auto Parts.

I think Thomas O’Malley was named after Tom in Tom and Jerry.

The part where Shun Gon slams a cymbal on his head reminds me of Dopey doing that.

Shun Gon’s been under fire in recent decades for being a racist stereotype. I’m completely against racism, however I can’t agree that Shun Gon really IS a racist stereotype; sure he’s saying “Shanghai Hong Kong Egg Foo Young” and “Fortune Cookie always Wrong” but that doesn’t translate to racism to me. Perhaps I’m not understanding the racism accusations here but I couldn’t find anything wrong with him. Besides, I’ve seen much, much worse; Scrub Me Mama With A Boogie Beat and All This and Rabbit Stew, two horrible cartoons from the 1940s come to mind.

Some of the cat designs look eerily similar to cats seen in An American Tail. Did Don Bluth work on this?

Cover for the first video release.

Pros

Edgar could file a lawsuit for that.
  1. Great animation, as typical for Walt Disney Productions (Now known as Walt Disney Pictures).
  2. Scenes with Edgar and the dogs. You have to watch them for yourself to understand where I’m going with this. Sure it’s considered filler but it’s still decent.
  3. O’Malley’s song after the wet night is the best song in the movie.
  4. Watching the alley cats literally bring down the house is one of the most epic moments in Disney history.
  5. Voice work is top notch and has some familiar faces, most notably Scatman Crothers who later was in Stanley Kubrick’s The Shining!
  6. Great humor in many areas, such as the Milkman – just look at O’Malley’s face as he’s clinging to the bottom back door flap!
  7. Amazing soundtrack composed by George Bruns.
No free rides.

Cons

  1. This is a big one. Edgar has got to be one of – if not THE worst Disney villain ever – yes, even more brain damaged than Aunt Sarah, Shan Yu or Hans (Frozen)! He literally thinks he’ll never get Madame Adelaide Bonfamille’s will just because he doesn’t understand SECOND GRADE MATH. Did this dipshit drop out of school or something?! He’s already dumber than the Ogre Magi from DOTA 2!
  2. Marie can go suck on a nut. I don’t care if she’s a spotlight stealing punk; she’s just as obnoxious as Princess Ruto in Ocarina of Time. She acts like a pompous bitch throughout the entire movie and pretty much has this “please euthanize me” attitude. Even as a kid I just wished she was left behind in that trunk with Edger going to Africa.
  3. The rest of the song numbers are pretty lousy. Scales and Arpeggios has been ranked as one of the worst songs by a reviewer.
  4. The plot itself is relatively similar to 101 Dalmatians.
Reckless driving is my pet peeve.
Marie from The Aristocats
Princess Ruto from Ocarina of Time

Can you spot the difference between these two? Neither can I. Both make me want to find a gun and blow their heads off.

Rating: 6.5/10 – Decent

Not the worst Disney movie out there, but compared to Robin Hood and the Rescuers this one doesn’t hold up. It’s been disliked by several reviewers – particularly a CERTAIN mysterious man. The weak song numbers and Marie’s annoyance knocked the rating down hard. Otherwise this one’s passable.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *